Everything about this bottle is a joke. The name is a fart gag with a fake doctorate attached. The label is got up like a Victorian hair tonic. It calls itself an “elixir of capsaicin extremus.” You buy it for someone as a laugh, or you get handed it as one.
Then you taste it, and the joke turns on you a little. There’s a real sauce in here, a Caribbean mustard number with more going on than most bottles that take themselves seriously. So the question with Professor Phardtpounder’s Colon Cleaner isn’t whether it’s funny. It’s whether a gag sauce can also be a good one. This one mostly is, and it gets there on flavor, not on the funny name alone.
Professor Phardtpounder's Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce
A Caribbean mustard sauce hiding inside a fart-joke bottle. Sweet, tangy, and curry-warm, with a scotch bonnet burn that hits fast and gets out of the way of the flavor.
Last update on 08/17/2026. We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
The Flavor
First thing in is sweet, which is not what a bottle called Colon Cleaner sets you up for. A little sugar up front, and right on its heels the sour comes through from the vinegar and the mustard. Sweet, then tangy, with mustard running under both. For a second or two it reads more like a sharp deli mustard than a hot sauce. It’s a distinctive way in, and an inviting one if mustard is your thing. If it isn’t, you’ll know right here, because the mustard is out front and it doesn’t apologize for itself.
The ingredient list is short and it tells you what kind of sauce you’re holding: scotch bonnet peppers, mustard, modified food starch, salt, onions, water, vinegar, turmeric, sugar, and a preservative. Scotch bonnet leads the list, which matters for the heat, but mustard and turmeric are what you actually taste. The turmeric is the tell. It puts a curry edge on everything, and once you catch it the sauce makes sense: this is a Caribbean mustard sauce, the sweet-hot-tangy kind that turns up alongside jerk or roti, just wearing a joke label. Sweet, sour, savory, and a little earthy all at once. For something sold as a novelty, there’s a real cook’s idea running through it, and it’s better built than the bottle lets on.
The tail end keeps the more interesting half. Once you swallow, what stays is the mustard and the turmeric, that curry warmth sitting on your tongue after everything else has moved off. Nothing sours or turns off on the way out. It leaves you with the spice rather than the sting.
Heat Balance
For something branded jokingly as a medicinal weapon, the heat is more well-mannered than the internet would lead you to believe. Scotch bonnet is the first ingredient on the ingredient list and the online estimates on the sauce’s Scoville heat units run wide for Colon Cleaner, from around 50,000 all the way up to 250,000 SHU.
That’s a wide range with some serious heat. And that’s not my eating experience. I think it’s in the range, but in the lower portion. Is it hot? For sure. But not north of 100,000 SHU hot. Scotch bonnets range from 100,000 to 350,000 SHU, so there’s room for this to be inconsistent heat levels due to where the peppers for a specific batch land. But, from my usage (three different bottles, bought or gifted years apart), I’d put it between 50,000 and 75,000 SHU. From a pepper perspective, think max cayenne level heat plus. Or right in the range of a Thai pepper (50,000 to 100,000 SHU).
So it’s hot, but the burn hits fast, makes its point, and backs off to a lingering warm hum pretty quickly. And it never climbs on top of the flavor. You taste the sweet, the mustard, and the curry the whole way through, with the heat running alongside those bold flavors instead of drowning them. The hotter a sauce get, the harder that is to control, and Colon Cleaner gets it right. Granted, mustard and turmeric are bolder flavors, so there’s more room for error compared to subtler ingredients.
Usability
This is where the mustard catches up with it. Colon Cleaner is excellent on the things it suits: eggs, a burger, jerk chicken, a curry, anything already reaching for mustard or Caribbean spice. It is not a put-it-on-anything bottle. The Dijon-and-turmeric profile that makes it interesting is the same thing that fences it in. Put it on a taco or a slice of pizza and you’ll taste the two of them arguing. And pretty loudly.
Tabasco and Sriracha go on everything because their ingredients are simple with broad use cases. Colon Cleaner tastes of something specific (and not all too common in hot sauces), and specific comes with a smaller map. That’s a fair trade for the flavor, but it’s the reason this scores where it does here.
Collectibility
If you collect hot sauce bottles, this one belongs at the front of the shelf.
The name is a fart joke with a PhD. The label is dressed up like a Victorian patent medicine, all curlicues and mock-serious promises about an elixir of capsaicin extremus. It comes in an apothecary-style bottle that looks like it should be locked in a case at an old pharmacy. And it isn’t all gag: it took second place in the Caribbean category at the 2004 Scovie Awards, so the sauce earns the shelf space the bottle demands.
It’s the one you turn label-out, and the one you hand a guest to watch them read the name. None of it is trying to be tasteful. That’s the whole point, and it’s why it works.
The Bottom Line
Buy Professor Phardtpounder’s Colon Cleaner for the laugh and keep it for the flavor. The name gets it onto the shelf and into the gift bag, but the Caribbean mustard sauce inside is better than the joke needs it to be: sweet, tangy, curry-warm, with a scotch bonnet burn that knows when to quit. It won’t go on everything, and if you can’t stand mustard it’s not your bottle. For everybody else it’s a genuinely good sauce in a clown suit, and I mean that as a compliment.
Get the free PepperScale Scoville Heat Chart
A printable, at-a-glance ranking of 25 chilies from sweet to scorching — with the jalapeño and Carolina Reaper as your reference points. Join the newsletter and we’ll send it straight to your inbox.
No spam — just Wicked Wednesday recipes and occasional extra dashes of chili pepper inspiration. Unsubscribe anytime.
Related Reading
- Our Hot Sauce Rankings: We review over 100 hot sauces. See how they stack up and let us help you find your next new fave.
- The Hot Pepper List: 170+ pepper profiled and counting. Get to know the chilies behind your favorite bottles.
- Fermented Vs. Unfermented Hot Sauce: How are they different? We dive in.
I love this hot sauce, and normally I’m a heat-wimp. Incredible flavor and a great thick consistency for eggs and tacos.