Hinkelhatz Pepper Guide: Heat, Flavor, Uses

When you think “Pennsylvania Dutch,” hot peppers don’t immediately come to mind. But there’s a surprising amount of heat to be found in the region well known for its farming. Along with the extra-hot Devil’s Tongue chili (profiled here), the Hinkelhatz pepper has its roots in Pennsylvania Dutch country, where it has been grown for more than 150 years. It has a medium spiciness (5,000 to 30,000 Scoville heat units) and a clean, simple flavor, making it perfect for its main uses among the Pennsylvania Dutch: pickling and hot pepper vinegar.

The name means “chicken heart” in Pennsylvania Dutch, after the pod’s small, blunt, heart-like shape. The pepper goes back a long way. A Pennsylvania Dutch cookbook from 1848 calls for it in pepper sauces, and today it’s on Slow Food’s Ark of Taste.

GROW YOUR OWN: Hinkelhatz Pepper Seeds
Fresh Hinkelhatz peppers are hard to find outside Pennsylvania Dutch country, but the compact plants are small enough to grow in a pot. The small red pods are made for pickling and pepper vinegar.

Last update on 2026-11-15. We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. 

A white stoneware bowl of glossy orange and red Hinkelhatz peppers on a linen cloth beside a window
Small, blunt and a little lumpy, the pods are shaped a bit like a chicken heart, which is where the name comes from.
Hinkelhatz Pepper Fast Facts
Loudest notes: Fresh, Bitter
Group A · Green & GrassyAroma families sort peppers by their loudest smell, not their heat.AGreen & Grassygreen, vegetal, just-cutBFruity & Tropicaltropical fruit, sweet on the noseCNutty, Earthy & Drieddried and smoked: raisin, cocoaDSharp, Pungent & Floralterpene top notes, heat unmasked
How hot?
How hot? Group A · Green & GrassyAroma families sort peppers by their loudest smell, not their heat.AGreen & Grassygreen, vegetal, just-cutBFruity & Tropicaltropical fruit, sweet on the noseCNutty, Earthy & Drieddried and smoked: raisin, cocoaDSharp, Pungent & Floralterpene top notes, heat unmasked
5,000–30,000 SHU
median ≈17,500 SHU
≈3.3×
a jalapeño's heat
Hinkelhatz
Bell Poblano Jalapeño Serrano Cayenne Habanero Reaper
In plain terms: hotter than a serrano, milder than a cayenne.
Flavor profile
Flavor profile Hinkelhatz Pepper
SweetFruityTangyFreshBitterSmokyEarthyFloral
Loudest notes: Fresh, Bitter
At a glance
Species
C. annuum
Origin
United States
Uses
Culinary

How hot is a Hinkelhatz pepper, really?

The Hinkelhatz runs 5,000 to 30,000 Scoville heat units, which is a wide range for a medium-heat chili. At the low end, one pod is about as hot as a jalapeño (2,500 to 8,000 SHU). At the top, the next one reaches the bottom of cayenne’s range (30,000 to 50,000 SHU).

Put another way, it runs from a mid-ranged jalapeño to about 12 times hotter. Pod for pod, the average Hinkelhatz is about 3 times hotter than an average jalapeño, right around a serrano. So one chili could be a very eatable, family-friendly low-medium sizzle, while the next delivers a solid (and for many uncomfortable) medium-heat smack. Even at the top, it is a far cry from extra-hot chilies, like the habanero.

What a Hinkelhatz pepper actually tastes like

The heat is the story here. Expecting fruit? The Hinkelhatz has little of the tropical sweetness you get from a habanero. It falls in our Green & Grassy aroma family, with a fresh, green flavor, a little bitterness and a light tang.

Cut one open, and the walls are thicker and juicier than you’d expect from a pod this small, under a tough, bumpy skin. That simple flavor and sturdy flesh are a big part of why it’s such a good pickling pepper: it doesn’t fight the vinegar, and the heat stands up in the jar.

How to pair a Hinkelhatz pepper

Since its flavor is mostly fresh and green, the Hinkelhatz goes best with sharp, tangy partners. Vinegar comes first, then cucumbers, cabbage, onions and green tomatoes, and that’s why a Hinkelhatz pepper vinegar is a classic splash over sauerkraut.

For contrast, give the heat something rich to cushion it. Pork, sausage, potatoes and buttered noodles all soften the bite, so pork and sauerkraut is a natural home for a few dashes of that vinegar.

What should you skip? Delicate, fruity pairings, since the Hinkelhatz doesn’t have the fruit to meet them, and the heat would be all you taste.

Cooking with Hinkelhatz peppers

Pickling and pepper vinegar are the classic uses, and the Pennsylvania Dutch rarely ate these peppers raw. Left intact, the pods make colorful pickles, and for pepper vinegar, the peppers are cooked, pureed and mixed with vinegar. Want to try it? Our hot pepper vinegar recipe is an easy place to start.

Its heat and simple flavor also make for a good Tabasco-style hot sauce. And while they’re rarely eaten raw, they can work well in fresh salsas to provide a certain pop, and spicy soups and chilies where you need a pepper with bold heat are good use cases too.

  • Don’t let the size fool you. A pod this small can carry a lot more heat than it looks like it would, and the next one may be hotter still.
  • Wear gloves. Like with any chili, it’s best to use kitchen gloves in the handling. And learn how to combat chili burn before it happens.
  • Pickle them whole. Their thick walls hold up well, so you can follow the same method as our pickled jalapeños.

Red, yellow and orange Hinkelhatz peppers

Hinkelhatz pods are small. Most measure about three-quarters of an inch wide and an inch to an inch and a half long. They hang down from the plant and taper to a blunt point, and the skin is covered in tiny bumps and wrinkles.

Most ripen from green to a glossy red, but the Pennsylvania Dutch grew more than one color. You can still find yellow Hinkelhatz seed, and a very rare orange version exists too.

Growing and finding Hinkelhatz peppers

Outside Pennsylvania Dutch country, fresh Hinkelhatz peppers (and products made from them) are hard to find. So how do you get some? Grow your own. The seeds are widely available from heirloom seed companies.

The plant stays compact, about 1½ to 2 feet tall, and small enough to grow in a pot and bring inside for the winter, since it’s a perennial grown as an annual. Expect the pods to ripen about 80 to 95 days after transplanting, which puts the harvest around mid-September in Pennsylvania. For seed starting, spacing and a zip code planner, see our Hinkelhatz planting guide. If you’re a fan of pickling peppers yourself, these really are an excellent option to grow in your garden.

The best Hinkelhatz pepper substitute

Need a stand-in? Try a serrano. Serranos share that fresh, green flavor, their heat lines up with the middle of the Hinkelhatz’s range, and they pickle well. For something milder, use a jalapeño. And for a vinegar with more kick, a few cayenne or chile de árbol peppers will push the heat toward the Hinkelhatz’s top end. Need more ideas? Our serrano substitute guide lists other peppers at this heat level.

The bottom line

The Hinkelhatz is a working pepper with a lot of history behind it. Small and simple in flavor, it packs more heat than its size suggests, and it has been doing the same job in Pennsylvania Dutch kitchens for well over a century. Do you like pickles or pepper vinegar? Then it’s worth a spot in your garden.

The PepperScale Scoville Heat Chart
Free printable

Get the free PepperScale Scoville Heat Chart

A printable, at-a-glance ranking of 25 chilies from sweet to scorching — with the jalapeño and Carolina Reaper as your reference points. Join the newsletter and we’ll send it straight to your inbox.

No spam — just Wicked Wednesday recipes and occasional extra dashes of chili pepper inspiration. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related reading

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Gulsah

Searching a name for the peppers bought from a bazaar in Turkiye and finally got one. They said its origin is Roumelia. I think it is “hinkelhatz” and used to cook a very thick sauce. If anyone knows the name please reply. Colurs are changing yellow-green-red.

AJ Lau

Great peppers and yes the Amish grow both the red and the yellow. Seeds were from Jimmy Pickles in Pennsylvania (not too far from the source) and my plants turned out great.